and distribution of real economic value.
Introduction: The Danger of a Service-Led Economy Without
a Strong Productive Base
In recent years, the service sector has assumed a prominent
position in many developing economies. Banking, telecommunications, financial
technology, retail, entertainment, transportation, real estate and professional
services have expanded, attracting investment, creating employment
opportunities and contributing significantly to gross domestic product (GDP).
At first glance, this appears to be a positive development.
A growing service sector can indicate economic modernisation, technological
advancement and increased commercial activity.
However, a fundamental question deserves attention: Can a
developing economy achieve sustainable prosperity when its service sector
expands without a corresponding transformation of agriculture and
manufacturing?
My position is that developing economies need a much
stronger base of productive agricultural and manufacturing enterprises than
many currently possess. The objective is not to undermine services or suggest
that they have little economic value. Rather, it is to recognise that a
vibrant service sector cannot fully compensate for an economy that produces too
little food, manufactures too few goods and relies excessively on imports to
meet domestic demand.
For countries such as Nigeria, the distinction is
particularly important. An economy may record impressive growth in
telecommunications, banking and financial services while continuing to struggle
with food insecurity, industrial underdevelopment, unemployment,
foreign-exchange shortages and a persistent dependence on imported goods.
The challenge, therefore, is not simply to grow the economy.
It is to transform its productive capacity.
1. Agriculture: The Foundation of Economic Development
Agriculture is more than an activity concerned with planting
crops and rearing livestock. It is a strategic sector that supports food
security, rural livelihoods, industrial development, export earnings and
national economic stability.
For many developing economies, agriculture remains one of
the largest sources of employment. Yet its potential is often constrained by
low productivity, inadequate infrastructure, limited access to finance,
insecurity, poor storage facilities and weak links to markets.
Consider Nigeria. The country has substantial agricultural potential, but potential alone does not guarantee prosperity. A nation can possess fertile land and a large population of farmers while still experiencing food insecurity and importing significant quantities of food. The problem is not necessarily a lack of agricultural activity. It is the insufficient commercialisation, mechanisation and industrial integration of that activity.
From subsistence farming to commercial agriculture
Developing economies must move beyond subsistence farming towards productive, technology-enabled and commercially viable agriculture. This transformation requires:
- Mechanisation
and modern farming techniques.
- Reliable
irrigation systems to reduce dependence on rainfall.
- Improved
seeds, fertilisers and agricultural research.
- Affordable
financing for farmers and agribusinesses.
- Better
rural roads and transportation networks.
- Storage
facilities and cold-chain infrastructure.
- Modern
processing and packaging facilities.
- Reliable
access to domestic and international markets.
The objective should be to increase output per hectare,
reduce post-harvest losses, improve farmers' incomes and establish agriculture
as a profitable commercial enterprise.
Agriculture must feed industry
One of the most important economic relationships is the connection between agriculture and manufacturing. A vibrant agricultural sector supplies raw materials to food processors, textile manufacturers, pharmaceutical companies, breweries, animal-feed producers and other industries.
For example, cassava can support the production of flour,
starch, industrial adhesives and other value-added products. Cocoa can be
processed into cocoa butter, powder and chocolate. Cotton can supply textile
mills, while oil palm can support food processing, cosmetics and other
industrial applications.
Each stage of processing creates opportunities for employment, investment, technological development and business expansion. Instead of exporting raw agricultural commodities and importing finished products, developing economies should progressively increase the proportion of their agricultural output processed domestically. The real economic opportunity lies not merely in producing more agricultural commodities, but in capturing more of the value generated from them. Agriculture should therefore be treated as a strategic foundation for industrialisation, rather than merely a source of food and rural employment.
2. Manufacturing: Turning Production into Prosperity
If agriculture provides the raw materials, manufacturing
transforms them into higher-value products.
Manufacturing is particularly important because it can
create linkages across the economy. A single factory may support farmers,
transport operators, packaging companies, equipment suppliers, financial
institutions, wholesalers, retailers and maintenance businesses.
The resulting economic activity extends far beyond the
factory floor.
Research published by the World Bank has historically
identified manufacturing as an important route to higher productivity,
employment creation and poverty reduction. The challenge for developing
economies is to build competitive industries capable of creating productive
jobs in an increasingly technology-driven global economy. World
Bank
Why manufacturing matters
First, manufacturing creates value addition.
A country that exports raw materials often captures less of the value than a country that processes them into finished goods. Consider cocoa. Selling raw cocoa beans generates export revenue. Processing those beans into cocoa powder, butter and chocolate can create additional opportunities in processing, packaging, branding, distribution and export marketing. The same principle applies to agricultural products, minerals, textiles and other raw materials.
Second, manufacturing can generate productive employment.
Factories employ machine operators, technicians, engineers, quality-control specialists, accountants, procurement professionals, logistics managers and other workers. They also create indirect employment through supply chains. This is especially important in developing economies with large and growing working-age populations.
Third, manufacturing can improve foreign-exchange
earnings.
Domestic production can reduce dependence on imported finished goods. Competitive manufacturers can also export their products, generating foreign currency. However, import substitution is not automatically beneficial. Domestic production must become sufficiently efficient and competitive to deliver good-quality products at sustainable prices.
Fourth, manufacturing promotes technological development.
Industrial enterprises encourage the acquisition of technical skills, machinery maintenance, quality management, research, product development and process improvement. These capabilities can spread across the wider economy.
Fifth, manufacturing supports economic resilience.
Countries that rely heavily on imports are vulnerable to exchange-rate depreciation, shipping disruptions, international price fluctuations and foreign supply shortages. Developing domestic production capacity can reduce some of these vulnerabilities, although no economy can or should manufacture everything it consumes.
The danger of premature deindustrialisation
A particularly serious concern arises when an economy's industrial sector stagnates or declines before the country has achieved high income levels. Economists refer to this phenomenon as premature deindustrialisation. Research discussed by the World Bank shows that some developing economies have experienced a declining industrial share at relatively low levels of development, limiting their ability to generate productive manufacturing employment. World Bank
This matters because an economy can move workers out of agriculture without moving them into sufficiently productive jobs. If workers leave farming only to enter low-productivity informal trading or other insecure activities, the economy may experience urbanisation without achieving substantial structural transformation.
The objective should not simply be to move people from
agriculture into services. It should be to move people and resources into
progressively more productive economic activities.
For developing economies, building competitive manufacturing
capacity is one important way to achieve that objective.
3. The Service Sector: Valuable, but Not a Substitute for
Production
It is important to clarify the central argument.
The service sector is indispensable to modern economic development. Banking, insurance, telecommunications, information technology, transport, logistics, education, healthcare, tourism and professional services all create value. Indeed, modern manufacturing and agriculture depend heavily on services.
Farmers require financial services, logistics, telecommunications, equipment maintenance and market information. Manufacturers require banking, insurance, advertising, software, transport, legal services and distribution networks. The issue is therefore not whether services are important. They are.
The issue is whether the growth of services is supported
by a sufficiently strong productive economy or whether it is occurring
alongside persistent weaknesses in domestic production.
The problem of service-led growth without productive
transformation
Imagine an economy in which banking, mobile telecommunications, financial technology, retail trading and property services are expanding rapidly. GDP may increase. Businesses may report higher revenues. Digital transactions may multiply. More people may enter commercial activities. Yet the country may still struggle to produce enough food, manufacture essential consumer goods, generate competitive exports or provide productive employment on the scale required. This can create a misleading impression of economic progress.
For example, the expansion of retail trading may reflect increased commercial activity, but if retailers mainly distribute imported goods, the associated demand may support production and employment elsewhere. Similarly, financial transactions may increase without a corresponding expansion of productive investment. Neither development is inherently harmful. Imported goods meet legitimate consumer and industrial needs, while financial services support economic activity. The concern arises when these activities dominate without adequate investment in domestic productive capacity.
A vibrant financial sector should finance productive
enterprises. A strong logistics sector should move goods efficiently. A modern
digital economy should help farmers and manufacturers reach markets, reduce
costs and improve productivity.
Services create the greatest developmental value when
they help the rest of the economy become more productive, competitive and
innovative.
What does the evidence say?
The World Bank's research on services-led development
cautions against dismissing services as an engine of economic growth. It finds
that services can generate productivity gains, employment and export
opportunities, particularly when technology, skills and trade are developed
effectively. It also highlights the importance of services that improve
manufacturing competitiveness. World
Bank Blogs
Consequently, the appropriate policy is not to suppress services in favour of agriculture and manufacturing. It is to build stronger connections between them.
4. The Structural Transformation Developing Economies
Need
Successful economic development involves more than an increase in the number of businesses or the value of transactions. It requires a sustained improvement in productivity, the complexity of production and the quality of employment. A useful framework is to consider how agriculture, manufacturing and services can reinforce one another.
|
Sector |
Primary economic contribution |
What developing economies should prioritise |
|
Agriculture |
Food security, raw materials, rural incomes and exports |
Mechanisation, irrigation, commercial farming, storage and
agro-processing |
|
Manufacturing |
Value addition, industrial jobs, technology and export
diversification |
Competitive factories, reliable energy, industrial skills
and local supply chains |
|
Services |
Finance, logistics, technology, distribution and
professional support |
Services that improve productivity, innovation and market
access across the economy |
The goal is not to maximise one sector at the expense of the
others. It is to create an integrated economic system in which each sector
strengthens the others.
The agricultural-manufacturing-services connection
Consider a domestic tomato value chain.
- Farmers
cultivate tomatoes using improved seeds and irrigation.
- Agricultural
suppliers provide fertilisers, machinery and technical advice.
- Manufacturers
process tomatoes into paste and other products.
- Packaging
companies supply containers and labels.
- Banks
finance working capital and equipment.
- Logistics
companies transport products to markets.
- Digital
platforms connect producers with wholesalers and retailers.
- Marketing
and distribution companies help products reach consumers.
This chain creates multiple business opportunities from a single agricultural product. Now imagine that the same model is applied to cassava, cocoa, rice, maize, palm oil, livestock, fish, cotton and other products. The potential is not limited to farming or food processing. It extends to machinery, packaging, chemicals, cold storage, software, transport, finance and export services. This is the type of interconnected production system that developing economies should seek to establish.
5. Lessons from Economies That Have Industrialised
Successfully
Although countries follow different development paths, the
experience of successful industrialising economies offers useful lessons.
South Korea: From agricultural development to industrial
competitiveness
South Korea's development illustrates the importance of
combining investment in human capital and infrastructure with industrial
development, technology acquisition and export competitiveness.
Its transformation was not achieved by expanding domestic
consumption alone. Firms developed the capacity to manufacture increasingly
sophisticated products and compete in international markets.
The broader lesson is that developing economies need
enterprises that can produce competitively, innovate continuously and move into
higher-value activities.
Vietnam: Integrating domestic production with global
markets
Vietnam demonstrates how manufacturing investment and
participation in global value chains can create employment and expand exports.
However, the long-term benefits depend partly on the extent
to which domestic firms develop capabilities, supply larger manufacturers and
capture more value within production networks.
Simply hosting factories is not enough. The objective should
be to deepen domestic supply chains and strengthen local productive
capabilities.
The broader lesson
Neither country provides a blueprint that can be copied without adaptation. Their institutional arrangements, geography, history and international circumstances differ from those of other developing economies. Nevertheless, their experiences reinforce an important principle:
Sustained development requires the accumulation of
productive capabilities, not merely the expansion of consumption and commercial
transactions.
The World Bank's research on structural transformation
similarly emphasises the importance of moving resources into more productive
activities while strengthening the skills, infrastructure and institutions
required for long-term growth. World
Bank Blogs
6. Nigeria: A Case for Stronger Agriculture and
Manufacturing
Nigeria provides a useful illustration of why this debate
matters.
The country has a large domestic market, substantial
agricultural potential, an entrepreneurial population and significant
opportunities in manufacturing and services.
Yet its productive potential remains constrained by several
challenges.
Agriculture
Agricultural productivity is affected by insecurity in some
farming areas, inadequate irrigation, limited mechanisation, post-harvest
losses, poor rural infrastructure and restricted access to affordable finance.
These problems raise production costs and reduce the
reliability of food supplies.
A stronger agricultural strategy should focus on commercial
production, rural infrastructure, modern storage, agricultural research and the
development of processing industries close to production areas.
Manufacturing
Manufacturers face challenges that include unreliable
electricity, expensive energy, transport bottlenecks, high financing costs,
exchange-rate volatility and competition from imported goods.
These conditions can make domestic production more expensive
and less predictable.
The solution requires a coordinated approach to
infrastructure, trade, finance, skills and industrial policy.
Services
Nigeria's financial services, telecommunications, technology
and commercial sectors have considerable potential. These industries should be
encouraged to support domestic production.
For example:
- Banks
can develop financing products suited to farmers and manufacturers.
- Digital
platforms can improve access to agricultural markets.
- Logistics
firms can reduce the cost of moving goods.
- Insurance
companies can help businesses manage production risks.
- Universities
and technology firms can support industrial research.
- Accountancy
and professional services can improve governance and financial management.
The priority should be to channel more of the country's
entrepreneurial energy and financial resources into productive enterprises.
Nigeria does not need fewer successful service businesses.
It needs more successful agricultural and manufacturing businesses,
supported by equally capable service providers.
7. What Governments Must Do to Change the Current
Trajectory
A productive economy does not emerge simply because a government announces an agricultural or industrial policy. Businesses need a commercial environment in which investment can generate sustainable returns. I would prioritise the following measures.
1. Make electricity reliable and affordable
Electricity is a fundamental input into modern agriculture
and manufacturing.
Unreliable power forces businesses to rely on alternative
energy sources, increasing operating costs and reducing competitiveness.
Investment in generation, transmission, distribution and
appropriate off-grid solutions should therefore be treated as a central
component of industrial policy.
2. Improve access to long-term finance
Agricultural and manufacturing investments often require
substantial initial expenditure before they generate returns.
Farmers need finance for land preparation, irrigation,
machinery and storage. Manufacturers need finance for factories, equipment,
inventory and working capital.
Financial institutions and governments should develop
sustainable financing arrangements that reflect the risks and cash-flow
characteristics of these sectors.
Public support should be transparent, commercially
disciplined and designed to crowd in private investment rather than permanently
subsidise inefficient enterprises.
3. Build infrastructure around productive clusters
Governments should identify areas where agricultural output,
labour, transport connections and market demand can support viable production
clusters.
These clusters could combine farms, processing facilities,
warehouses, packaging businesses, transport services and export infrastructure.
Such an approach can reduce logistics costs, improve
coordination and make it easier for smaller enterprises to participate in
supply chains.
4. Promote agro-processing and local value addition
Incentives should encourage the transformation of raw
agricultural commodities into higher-value products.
However, incentives must be carefully designed.
Indiscriminate import restrictions or prolonged protection can raise consumer
prices and shield inefficient businesses from competition.
The aim should be to develop productive enterprises capable
of competing on quality, price and reliability.
5. Invest in technical and vocational skills
Manufacturing and modern agriculture require technicians,
engineers, machine operators, maintenance specialists, quality-control
professionals and skilled managers.
Education and training systems should work more closely with
employers to ensure that workers acquire the skills businesses actually need.
6. Improve trade and export competitiveness
Domestic producers need access to reliable transport,
efficient ports, predictable customs procedures and clear product standards.
Governments should support businesses in meeting
international quality requirements and accessing regional and global markets.
The African Continental Free Trade Area offers an
opportunity to expand trade, provided participating economies address
infrastructure, regulatory and non-tariff barriers.
7. Measure outcomes, not announcements
Governments frequently announce investment programmes, financing schemes and industrial projects. But the more meaningful questions are:
- How
many productive enterprises have become operational?
- How
much additional output is being produced?
- How
many sustainable jobs have been created?
- Have
domestic supply chains become stronger?
- Are
exports increasing?
- Has
food productivity improved?
- Are
businesses becoming more competitive without permanent protection?
Public policy should be evaluated against measurable
economic outcomes rather than the number of initiatives announced.
8. A Word of Caution: Agriculture and Manufacturing Must
Also Become Productive
The argument for stronger agriculture and manufacturing
should not be interpreted as a call to protect every farm or factory regardless
of performance.
Agricultural enterprises can remain unproductive. Factories
can waste capital, pollute the environment and produce goods that consumers do
not want. Industrial policy can fail when political considerations override
commercial realities.
The objective is not merely to increase the number of farms
and factories. It is to increase the number of productive, competitive,
innovative and sustainable enterprises.
Agriculture must become more productive per worker and per
hectare. Manufacturing must improve quality, efficiency and technological
capability.
Both sectors must adapt to climate risks, resource
constraints and changing consumer demand.
They must also embrace digital technology. Precision
agriculture, data analytics, automated production, digital payments and modern
logistics can help developing economies leapfrog some traditional constraints.
The service sector has an important role here. Technology
companies, financial institutions, research organisations and professional
service providers can help farms and factories become more efficient.
The most promising model is therefore not an economy
dominated by agriculture and manufacturing while services stagnate. It is an
economy in which agriculture and manufacturing form a strong productive core,
supported by dynamic and innovative services.
9. Conclusion: Development Requires More Than
Transactions
A developing economy cannot sustainably consume its way to
prosperity, nor can it rely indefinitely on the expansion of commercial
transactions without building a stronger productive base.
Banking transactions, digital payments, telecommunications
subscriptions, retail sales and financial services are important indicators of
economic activity. But they do not, on their own, establish that a country has
developed the capacity to feed its population, manufacture competitive
products, create productive employment and earn foreign exchange sustainably.
Agriculture feeds the population and supplies raw materials.
Manufacturing transforms those materials into higher-value products. Services
provide the finance, technology, logistics, distribution and professional
expertise that enable both sectors to flourish.
These functions are complementary.
The central challenge for developing economies is to ensure
that the service sector does not become an island of commercial activity
disconnected from the wider productive economy.
For Nigeria and similar economies, the priority should be to
mobilise capital, skills, technology and entrepreneurial energy towards
productive agricultural and manufacturing enterprises while continuing to
develop a competitive service sector.
The ultimate measure of economic progress is not simply how
much money changes hands. It is how effectively a country converts its natural
resources, human capital and entrepreneurial talent into goods, services, jobs,
exports and improved living standards.
A vibrant service sector can facilitate development, but
a strong productive economy gives that development greater depth, resilience
and staying power.
The path to sustainable prosperity lies in building an
economy that produces more, processes more, exports more and creates more
productive opportunities for its people.
In short: developing economies do not need to choose between agriculture, manufacturing and services. They need to make agriculture and manufacturing stronger, and ensure that services work harder to support productive transformation.
References and further reading
- World
Bank, At Your Service? The Promise of Services-Led Development. World
Bank publication
- World
Bank, How Can We Generate More Good Jobs in Developing Countries? World
Bank development blog
- United
Nations Industrial Development Organization (UNIDO), Industrial
Development Report 2026. UNIDO
Industrial Development Report 2026
- World
Bank, Structural Change, Fundamentals, and Growth. World
Bank research publication
