Friday, November 20, 2026

Beyond Services: Why Developing Economies Need Stronger Agricultural and Manufacturing Sectors

 A nation's economic future cannot be secured by services alone. Sustainable development requires productive farms, competitive factories and a service sector that supports the production, transformation
and distribution of real economic value.

Introduction: The Danger of a Service-Led Economy Without a Strong Productive Base

In recent years, the service sector has assumed a prominent position in many developing economies. Banking, telecommunications, financial technology, retail, entertainment, transportation, real estate and professional services have expanded, attracting investment, creating employment opportunities and contributing significantly to gross domestic product (GDP).

At first glance, this appears to be a positive development. A growing service sector can indicate economic modernisation, technological advancement and increased commercial activity.

However, a fundamental question deserves attention: Can a developing economy achieve sustainable prosperity when its service sector expands without a corresponding transformation of agriculture and manufacturing?

My position is that developing economies need a much stronger base of productive agricultural and manufacturing enterprises than many currently possess. The objective is not to undermine services or suggest that they have little economic value. Rather, it is to recognise that a vibrant service sector cannot fully compensate for an economy that produces too little food, manufactures too few goods and relies excessively on imports to meet domestic demand.

For countries such as Nigeria, the distinction is particularly important. An economy may record impressive growth in telecommunications, banking and financial services while continuing to struggle with food insecurity, industrial underdevelopment, unemployment, foreign-exchange shortages and a persistent dependence on imported goods.

The challenge, therefore, is not simply to grow the economy. It is to transform its productive capacity.


1. Agriculture: The Foundation of Economic Development

Agriculture is more than an activity concerned with planting crops and rearing livestock. It is a strategic sector that supports food security, rural livelihoods, industrial development, export earnings and national economic stability.

For many developing economies, agriculture remains one of the largest sources of employment. Yet its potential is often constrained by low productivity, inadequate infrastructure, limited access to finance, insecurity, poor storage facilities and weak links to markets.

Consider Nigeria. The country has substantial agricultural potential, but potential alone does not guarantee prosperity. A nation can possess fertile land and a large population of farmers while still experiencing food insecurity and importing significant quantities of food. The problem is not necessarily a lack of agricultural activity. It is the insufficient commercialisation, mechanisation and industrial integration of that activity. 

From subsistence farming to commercial agriculture

Developing economies must move beyond subsistence farming towards productive, technology-enabled and commercially viable agriculture. This transformation requires:

  • Mechanisation and modern farming techniques.
  • Reliable irrigation systems to reduce dependence on rainfall.
  • Improved seeds, fertilisers and agricultural research.
  • Affordable financing for farmers and agribusinesses.
  • Better rural roads and transportation networks.
  • Storage facilities and cold-chain infrastructure.
  • Modern processing and packaging facilities.
  • Reliable access to domestic and international markets.

The objective should be to increase output per hectare, reduce post-harvest losses, improve farmers' incomes and establish agriculture as a profitable commercial enterprise.

Agriculture must feed industry

One of the most important economic relationships is the connection between agriculture and manufacturing. A vibrant agricultural sector supplies raw materials to food processors, textile manufacturers, pharmaceutical companies, breweries, animal-feed producers and other industries.

For example, cassava can support the production of flour, starch, industrial adhesives and other value-added products. Cocoa can be processed into cocoa butter, powder and chocolate. Cotton can supply textile mills, while oil palm can support food processing, cosmetics and other industrial applications.

Each stage of processing creates opportunities for employment, investment, technological development and business expansion. Instead of exporting raw agricultural commodities and importing finished products, developing economies should progressively increase the proportion of their agricultural output processed domestically. The real economic opportunity lies not merely in producing more agricultural commodities, but in capturing more of the value generated from them. Agriculture should therefore be treated as a strategic foundation for industrialisation, rather than merely a source of food and rural employment.

2. Manufacturing: Turning Production into Prosperity

If agriculture provides the raw materials, manufacturing transforms them into higher-value products.

Manufacturing is particularly important because it can create linkages across the economy. A single factory may support farmers, transport operators, packaging companies, equipment suppliers, financial institutions, wholesalers, retailers and maintenance businesses.

The resulting economic activity extends far beyond the factory floor.

Research published by the World Bank has historically identified manufacturing as an important route to higher productivity, employment creation and poverty reduction. The challenge for developing economies is to build competitive industries capable of creating productive jobs in an increasingly technology-driven global economy. World Bank

Why manufacturing matters

First, manufacturing creates value addition.

A country that exports raw materials often captures less of the value than a country that processes them into finished goods. Consider cocoa. Selling raw cocoa beans generates export revenue. Processing those beans into cocoa powder, butter and chocolate can create additional opportunities in processing, packaging, branding, distribution and export marketing. The same principle applies to agricultural products, minerals, textiles and other raw materials.

Second, manufacturing can generate productive employment.

Factories employ machine operators, technicians, engineers, quality-control specialists, accountants, procurement professionals, logistics managers and other workers. They also create indirect employment through supply chains. This is especially important in developing economies with large and growing working-age populations.

Third, manufacturing can improve foreign-exchange earnings.

Domestic production can reduce dependence on imported finished goods. Competitive manufacturers can also export their products, generating foreign currency. However, import substitution is not automatically beneficial. Domestic production must become sufficiently efficient and competitive to deliver good-quality products at sustainable prices.

Fourth, manufacturing promotes technological development.

Industrial enterprises encourage the acquisition of technical skills, machinery maintenance, quality management, research, product development and process improvement. These capabilities can spread across the wider economy.

Fifth, manufacturing supports economic resilience.

Countries that rely heavily on imports are vulnerable to exchange-rate depreciation, shipping disruptions, international price fluctuations and foreign supply shortages. Developing domestic production capacity can reduce some of these vulnerabilities, although no economy can or should manufacture everything it consumes.

The danger of premature deindustrialisation

A particularly serious concern arises when an economy's industrial sector stagnates or declines before the country has achieved high income levels. Economists refer to this phenomenon as premature deindustrialisation. Research discussed by the World Bank shows that some developing economies have experienced a declining industrial share at relatively low levels of development, limiting their ability to generate productive manufacturing employment. World Bank

This matters because an economy can move workers out of agriculture without moving them into sufficiently productive jobs. If workers leave farming only to enter low-productivity informal trading or other insecure activities, the economy may experience urbanisation without achieving substantial structural transformation.

The objective should not simply be to move people from agriculture into services. It should be to move people and resources into progressively more productive economic activities.

For developing economies, building competitive manufacturing capacity is one important way to achieve that objective.

3. The Service Sector: Valuable, but Not a Substitute for Production

It is important to clarify the central argument.

The service sector is indispensable to modern economic development. Banking, insurance, telecommunications, information technology, transport, logistics, education, healthcare, tourism and professional services all create value. Indeed, modern manufacturing and agriculture depend heavily on services.

Farmers require financial services, logistics, telecommunications, equipment maintenance and market information. Manufacturers require banking, insurance, advertising, software, transport, legal services and distribution networks. The issue is therefore not whether services are important. They are.

The issue is whether the growth of services is supported by a sufficiently strong productive economy or whether it is occurring alongside persistent weaknesses in domestic production.

The problem of service-led growth without productive transformation

Imagine an economy in which banking, mobile telecommunications, financial technology, retail trading and property services are expanding rapidly. GDP may increase. Businesses may report higher revenues. Digital transactions may multiply. More people may enter commercial activities. Yet the country may still struggle to produce enough food, manufacture essential consumer goods, generate competitive exports or provide productive employment on the scale required. This can create a misleading impression of economic progress.

For example, the expansion of retail trading may reflect increased commercial activity, but if retailers mainly distribute imported goods, the associated demand may support production and employment elsewhere. Similarly, financial transactions may increase without a corresponding expansion of productive investment. Neither development is inherently harmful. Imported goods meet legitimate consumer and industrial needs, while financial services support economic activity. The concern arises when these activities dominate without adequate investment in domestic productive capacity.

A vibrant financial sector should finance productive enterprises. A strong logistics sector should move goods efficiently. A modern digital economy should help farmers and manufacturers reach markets, reduce costs and improve productivity.

Services create the greatest developmental value when they help the rest of the economy become more productive, competitive and innovative.

What does the evidence say?

The World Bank's research on services-led development cautions against dismissing services as an engine of economic growth. It finds that services can generate productivity gains, employment and export opportunities, particularly when technology, skills and trade are developed effectively. It also highlights the importance of services that improve manufacturing competitiveness. World Bank Blogs

Consequently, the appropriate policy is not to suppress services in favour of agriculture and manufacturing. It is to build stronger connections between them.


4. The Structural Transformation Developing Economies Need

Successful economic development involves more than an increase in the number of businesses or the value of transactions. It requires a sustained improvement in productivity, the complexity of production and the quality of employment. A useful framework is to consider how agriculture, manufacturing and services can reinforce one another.

Sector

Primary economic contribution

What developing economies should prioritise

Agriculture

Food security, raw materials, rural incomes and exports

Mechanisation, irrigation, commercial farming, storage and agro-processing

Manufacturing

Value addition, industrial jobs, technology and export diversification

Competitive factories, reliable energy, industrial skills and local supply chains

Services

Finance, logistics, technology, distribution and professional support

Services that improve productivity, innovation and market access across the economy

The goal is not to maximise one sector at the expense of the others. It is to create an integrated economic system in which each sector strengthens the others.

The agricultural-manufacturing-services connection

Consider a domestic tomato value chain.

  1. Farmers cultivate tomatoes using improved seeds and irrigation.
  2. Agricultural suppliers provide fertilisers, machinery and technical advice.
  3. Manufacturers process tomatoes into paste and other products.
  4. Packaging companies supply containers and labels.
  5. Banks finance working capital and equipment.
  6. Logistics companies transport products to markets.
  7. Digital platforms connect producers with wholesalers and retailers.
  8. Marketing and distribution companies help products reach consumers.

This chain creates multiple business opportunities from a single agricultural product. Now imagine that the same model is applied to cassava, cocoa, rice, maize, palm oil, livestock, fish, cotton and other products. The potential is not limited to farming or food processing. It extends to machinery, packaging, chemicals, cold storage, software, transport, finance and export services. This is the type of interconnected production system that developing economies should seek to establish.


5. Lessons from Economies That Have Industrialised Successfully

Although countries follow different development paths, the experience of successful industrialising economies offers useful lessons.

South Korea: From agricultural development to industrial competitiveness

South Korea's development illustrates the importance of combining investment in human capital and infrastructure with industrial development, technology acquisition and export competitiveness.

Its transformation was not achieved by expanding domestic consumption alone. Firms developed the capacity to manufacture increasingly sophisticated products and compete in international markets.

The broader lesson is that developing economies need enterprises that can produce competitively, innovate continuously and move into higher-value activities.

Vietnam: Integrating domestic production with global markets

Vietnam demonstrates how manufacturing investment and participation in global value chains can create employment and expand exports.

However, the long-term benefits depend partly on the extent to which domestic firms develop capabilities, supply larger manufacturers and capture more value within production networks.

Simply hosting factories is not enough. The objective should be to deepen domestic supply chains and strengthen local productive capabilities.

The broader lesson

Neither country provides a blueprint that can be copied without adaptation. Their institutional arrangements, geography, history and international circumstances differ from those of other developing economies. Nevertheless, their experiences reinforce an important principle:

Sustained development requires the accumulation of productive capabilities, not merely the expansion of consumption and commercial transactions.

The World Bank's research on structural transformation similarly emphasises the importance of moving resources into more productive activities while strengthening the skills, infrastructure and institutions required for long-term growth. World Bank Blogs


6. Nigeria: A Case for Stronger Agriculture and Manufacturing

Nigeria provides a useful illustration of why this debate matters.

The country has a large domestic market, substantial agricultural potential, an entrepreneurial population and significant opportunities in manufacturing and services.

Yet its productive potential remains constrained by several challenges.

Agriculture

Agricultural productivity is affected by insecurity in some farming areas, inadequate irrigation, limited mechanisation, post-harvest losses, poor rural infrastructure and restricted access to affordable finance.

These problems raise production costs and reduce the reliability of food supplies.

A stronger agricultural strategy should focus on commercial production, rural infrastructure, modern storage, agricultural research and the development of processing industries close to production areas.

Manufacturing

Manufacturers face challenges that include unreliable electricity, expensive energy, transport bottlenecks, high financing costs, exchange-rate volatility and competition from imported goods.

These conditions can make domestic production more expensive and less predictable.

The solution requires a coordinated approach to infrastructure, trade, finance, skills and industrial policy.

Services

Nigeria's financial services, telecommunications, technology and commercial sectors have considerable potential. These industries should be encouraged to support domestic production.

For example:

  • Banks can develop financing products suited to farmers and manufacturers.
  • Digital platforms can improve access to agricultural markets.
  • Logistics firms can reduce the cost of moving goods.
  • Insurance companies can help businesses manage production risks.
  • Universities and technology firms can support industrial research.
  • Accountancy and professional services can improve governance and financial management.

The priority should be to channel more of the country's entrepreneurial energy and financial resources into productive enterprises.

Nigeria does not need fewer successful service businesses. It needs more successful agricultural and manufacturing businesses, supported by equally capable service providers.


7. What Governments Must Do to Change the Current Trajectory

A productive economy does not emerge simply because a government announces an agricultural or industrial policy. Businesses need a commercial environment in which investment can generate sustainable returns. I would prioritise the following measures.

1. Make electricity reliable and affordable

Electricity is a fundamental input into modern agriculture and manufacturing.

Unreliable power forces businesses to rely on alternative energy sources, increasing operating costs and reducing competitiveness.

Investment in generation, transmission, distribution and appropriate off-grid solutions should therefore be treated as a central component of industrial policy.

2. Improve access to long-term finance

Agricultural and manufacturing investments often require substantial initial expenditure before they generate returns.

Farmers need finance for land preparation, irrigation, machinery and storage. Manufacturers need finance for factories, equipment, inventory and working capital.

Financial institutions and governments should develop sustainable financing arrangements that reflect the risks and cash-flow characteristics of these sectors.

Public support should be transparent, commercially disciplined and designed to crowd in private investment rather than permanently subsidise inefficient enterprises.

3. Build infrastructure around productive clusters

Governments should identify areas where agricultural output, labour, transport connections and market demand can support viable production clusters.

These clusters could combine farms, processing facilities, warehouses, packaging businesses, transport services and export infrastructure.

Such an approach can reduce logistics costs, improve coordination and make it easier for smaller enterprises to participate in supply chains.

4. Promote agro-processing and local value addition

Incentives should encourage the transformation of raw agricultural commodities into higher-value products.

However, incentives must be carefully designed. Indiscriminate import restrictions or prolonged protection can raise consumer prices and shield inefficient businesses from competition.

The aim should be to develop productive enterprises capable of competing on quality, price and reliability.

5. Invest in technical and vocational skills

Manufacturing and modern agriculture require technicians, engineers, machine operators, maintenance specialists, quality-control professionals and skilled managers.

Education and training systems should work more closely with employers to ensure that workers acquire the skills businesses actually need.

6. Improve trade and export competitiveness

Domestic producers need access to reliable transport, efficient ports, predictable customs procedures and clear product standards.

Governments should support businesses in meeting international quality requirements and accessing regional and global markets.

The African Continental Free Trade Area offers an opportunity to expand trade, provided participating economies address infrastructure, regulatory and non-tariff barriers.

7. Measure outcomes, not announcements

Governments frequently announce investment programmes, financing schemes and industrial projects. But the more meaningful questions are:

  • How many productive enterprises have become operational?
  • How much additional output is being produced?
  • How many sustainable jobs have been created?
  • Have domestic supply chains become stronger?
  • Are exports increasing?
  • Has food productivity improved?
  • Are businesses becoming more competitive without permanent protection?

Public policy should be evaluated against measurable economic outcomes rather than the number of initiatives announced.


8. A Word of Caution: Agriculture and Manufacturing Must Also Become Productive

The argument for stronger agriculture and manufacturing should not be interpreted as a call to protect every farm or factory regardless of performance.

Agricultural enterprises can remain unproductive. Factories can waste capital, pollute the environment and produce goods that consumers do not want. Industrial policy can fail when political considerations override commercial realities.

The objective is not merely to increase the number of farms and factories. It is to increase the number of productive, competitive, innovative and sustainable enterprises.

Agriculture must become more productive per worker and per hectare. Manufacturing must improve quality, efficiency and technological capability.

Both sectors must adapt to climate risks, resource constraints and changing consumer demand.

They must also embrace digital technology. Precision agriculture, data analytics, automated production, digital payments and modern logistics can help developing economies leapfrog some traditional constraints.

The service sector has an important role here. Technology companies, financial institutions, research organisations and professional service providers can help farms and factories become more efficient.

The most promising model is therefore not an economy dominated by agriculture and manufacturing while services stagnate. It is an economy in which agriculture and manufacturing form a strong productive core, supported by dynamic and innovative services.


9. Conclusion: Development Requires More Than Transactions

A developing economy cannot sustainably consume its way to prosperity, nor can it rely indefinitely on the expansion of commercial transactions without building a stronger productive base.

Banking transactions, digital payments, telecommunications subscriptions, retail sales and financial services are important indicators of economic activity. But they do not, on their own, establish that a country has developed the capacity to feed its population, manufacture competitive products, create productive employment and earn foreign exchange sustainably.

Agriculture feeds the population and supplies raw materials. Manufacturing transforms those materials into higher-value products. Services provide the finance, technology, logistics, distribution and professional expertise that enable both sectors to flourish.

These functions are complementary.

The central challenge for developing economies is to ensure that the service sector does not become an island of commercial activity disconnected from the wider productive economy.

For Nigeria and similar economies, the priority should be to mobilise capital, skills, technology and entrepreneurial energy towards productive agricultural and manufacturing enterprises while continuing to develop a competitive service sector.

The ultimate measure of economic progress is not simply how much money changes hands. It is how effectively a country converts its natural resources, human capital and entrepreneurial talent into goods, services, jobs, exports and improved living standards.

A vibrant service sector can facilitate development, but a strong productive economy gives that development greater depth, resilience and staying power.

The path to sustainable prosperity lies in building an economy that produces more, processes more, exports more and creates more productive opportunities for its people.

In short: developing economies do not need to choose between agriculture, manufacturing and services. They need to make agriculture and manufacturing stronger, and ensure that services work harder to support productive transformation.


'Segun-Martins Ogunyemi, FCA
...creating & adding values with ICE (Integrity, Contentment & Excellence)





References and further reading

 

Tuesday, October 6, 2026

Financial Doping: When Money Creates an Illusion of Competitive Strength

 In sport, doping refers to the use of prohibited substances or methods to enhance performance beyond what would ordinarily be achieved through training and natural ability. But what happens when the performance-enhancing substance is money?

That is the idea behind financial doping.

The term is most commonly used in sports economics, particularly football, to describe situations where clubs use unusually large injections of external finance – often from wealthy owners, lenders or related parties – to spend beyond what their underlying operating revenues would ordinarily support. Academic research has explicitly examined the concept in the English Premier League and its relationship with competitive advantage. (Taylor & Francis Online)

However, the underlying economic phenomenon extends beyond football. In broader financial and corporate contexts, similar dynamics can arise when cheap credit, government subsidies, guarantees or continuing financial support allow economically weak organisations to survive and compete against organisations operating without comparable assistance.

The fundamental question is therefore: When does financial support become a legitimate investment, and when does it become an artificial performance enhancer?


1. What Exactly Is Financial Doping?

Financial doping can be understood as the use of exceptional, subsidised, external or artificially structured financial resources to enhance competitive performance beyond what an organisation's underlying operating capacity would normally permit.

Consider two football clubs.

Club A generates £300 million of sustainable annual revenue and spends £250 million on players and wages.

Club B generates only £100 million but receives substantial owner funding and loans, allowing it to spend £250 million as well.

On the surface, both clubs may be spending £250 million. Economically, however, they are not operating from the same financial base. Club B has effectively obtained an additional source of competitive capacity. This does not automatically mean that Club B has done anything illegal. Investment is not the same as doping. An owner investing capital in a business may be entirely legitimate.

The concern arises when financial resources:

  • circumvent applicable financial restrictions;
  • conceal the true economic position of the organisation;
  • allow persistent spending unrelated to sustainable revenue;
  • keep fundamentally unviable businesses alive;
  • distort competition;
  • or create advantages unavailable to competitors operating under normal market constraints.

2. Financial Doping Is Not Simply “Having More Money”

This distinction is important. A company with £10 billion in revenue is not necessarily financially doping simply because it can spend more than a company with £100 million in revenue. Similarly, an entrepreneur investing personal capital into a start-up is not automatically engaging in financial doping.

Competitive advantage arising from genuine productivity, innovation, investment or superior business performance is a normal feature of capitalism. Financial doping becomes problematic when the source or structure of finance artificially disconnects competitive spending from sustainable economic capacity or regulatory constraints. This distinction is particularly important in professional sport.

Research on the English Premier League found evidence that money and investment can translate into sporting performance, raising questions about the competitive consequences of large financial injections. The researchers examined the relationship between financial investment and sporting success and argued that regulation is necessary to address potential distortions. (Taylor & Francis Online)


3. The Football Laboratory: Financial Doping in the Premier League

Football provides perhaps the clearest real-world laboratory for understanding financial doping.

Before UEFA and domestic financial regulations became more restrictive, some clubs could use loans from owners and banks to finance player acquisitions and wage expenditure at levels that their operating revenues could not independently support.

A 2024 empirical study of English Premier League clubs found that, before Financial Fair Play restrictions, the amount clubs spent on player acquisitions could exceed what their revenues could fund, with the difference being covered through bank and owner financing. The authors explicitly describe this phenomenon as “financial doping.” (DOI)

This creates an important economic mechanism: External finance → greater spending capacity → stronger squad → improved sporting performance → potentially higher revenues.

  • And this can become self-reinforcing. ·  A club spends heavily. ·  It attracts better players.
  • It performs better. · It qualifies for lucrative competitions. · It attracts more supporters and sponsors. ·  Its revenues increase. ·  It then has even greater capacity to spend.

This creates what economists might describe as a feedback loop between financial capacity and competitive performance.


4. Manchester City: A Contemporary Case Study

The debate over Manchester City illustrates why financial doping remains such a controversial concept.

In September 2026, an independent Premier League commission found Manchester City guilty of breaching financial regulations, following allegations concerning commercial revenues and related-party funding. Reuters reported that the commission found that sham commercial contracts had been used to disguise £831 million of equity funding as sponsorship income over a nine-year period ending in 2018. Manchester City has denied the findings and said it intends to appeal. (Reuters)

The case is particularly important because the alleged mechanism is not simply: “A wealthy owner spent money.” The much more fundamental issue is whether money was presented as something economically different from what it actually was. That distinction goes to the heart of financial regulation.

If equity funding is presented as commercial revenue, the reported financial capacity of the organisation can appear stronger than its underlying economics.

That can potentially affect:

  • expenditure limits;
  • player recruitment;
  • wage commitments;
  • regulatory compliance;
  • competitive balance.

It is therefore useful to distinguish between financial capacity and financial presentation. A club may have substantial financial backing. That is one thing. But if the source or nature of that backing is misrepresented to circumvent financial controls, that is an entirely different issue.

Manchester City has disputed the commission's findings, so the case should be understood as a contested regulatory matter subject to appeal rather than as an uncontested factual account of wrongdoing. (Reuters)


5. Financial Doping Does Not Belong Only to Football

The concept becomes even more interesting when we move from football to the wider economy. Imagine a manufacturing company that consistently makes losses. It cannot generate enough operating cash to service its debt. Yet banks continue lending to it at unusually favourable rates. Government subsidies keep arriving. Its creditors continue rolling over existing loans. Instead of restructuring or exiting the market, the company continues operating. This company may become what economists call a zombie firm.

The World Bank defines non-viable zombie firms as firms generating enough income to service interest but not enough to repay their outstanding debt. Such firms can absorb resources that could otherwise be deployed by more productive businesses. (World Bank)

This is not necessarily fraud. It is a different economic problem: Financial support can sometimes keep an economically weak organisation alive long after the market would otherwise have forced restructuring or exit. That is one of the broader economic parallels with financial doping.


6. Empirical Evidence: Zombie Firms Around the World

This is not merely theoretical. A large international study covering firms across 79 countries between 2005 and 2016 found that zombie firms represented roughly 10% of the observations in its dataset. The research also found that stronger debt-enforcement environments were associated with fewer zombie firms. (ScienceDirect)

This matters because capital is not unlimited. If £1 million is committed to an inefficient company that is being kept alive artificially, that £1 million cannot simultaneously be used by another company with a potentially higher return. The issue is therefore not simply: “Is the weak company receiving money?” And the deeper question is “What is the opportunity cost of keeping that company alive?”


7. China Provides Another Empirical Example

Research using firm-level manufacturing data in China provides further evidence.

A 2025 study published in Economica examined zombie firms and state subsidies. The researchers found that zombie firms were, on average, larger and less productive than non-zombie firms and received higher subsidy rates. Their modelling suggested that reducing subsidy dispersion and facilitating the exit of zombie firms could reduce zombie activity and improve aggregate productivity. (Wiley Online Library)

This is a fascinating finding. A subsidy can have a perfectly legitimate economic purpose. Governments may subsidise businesses to:

  • encourage innovation;
  • protect employment;
  • develop strategic industries;
  • support investment;
  • address market failures;
  • stimulate regional development.

The problem arises when financial support becomes disconnected from productivity. At that point, the subsidy may stop being a bridge to competitiveness and become a life-support mechanism for inefficiency.


8. The Moral Hazard Problem

Financial doping creates an important concept in economics: Moral hazard. If an organisation knows that someone else will continually absorb the consequences of its financial decisions, its incentives can change. Consider two businesses.

Business A

The owner knows: “If I make a bad investment, I bear the loss.” The owner therefore has a strong incentive to assess:

  • return on investment;
  • cash flow;
  • risk;
  • productivity;
  • cost control.

Business B

Management believes: “If things go wrong, the owner will inject more money.”

Or: “The government will subsidise us.”

Or: “The bank will simply roll over the debt.”

The incentive to impose financial discipline may weaken.

Research on Chinese industrial firms found that moral hazard associated with financial instability made subsidies less effective in improving efficiency and profitability among zombie firms. (ScienceDirect)

This is why financial doping can create a dangerous cycle:

Poor performance → financial support → reduced pressure to restructure → continued poor performance → further financial support.


9. Financial Doping Can Punish Efficient Competitors

This may be the most important economic consequence. Imagine two companies competing in the same market.

Company A

  • controls costs;
  • invests carefully;
  • manages working capital;
  • pays market interest rates;
  • restructures when necessary;
  • exits unprofitable markets.

Company B

  • receives subsidised finance;
  • enjoys government support;
  • has access to cheap related-party funding;
  • continues loss-making operations.

Company B may now sell products at prices that Company A cannot sustainably match.

The result can be resource misallocation. Research on zombie firms has found evidence that zombie firms can negatively affect the operating efficiency of normal firms and increase their debt-financing costs. (DOI) 

In other words, financial support for one inefficient organisation can impose costs on organisations that are financially healthy. This is why financial doping is ultimately a competition issue.


10. Financial Doping Can Create the Illusion of Success

There is another dimension that deserves attention. Money can sometimes conceal underlying weaknesses. A company can appear successful because it has:

  • abundant funding;
  • aggressive acquisition programmes;
  • rapid expansion;
  • expensive marketing;
  • large offices;
  • high employee numbers;
  • impressive technology;
  • substantial assets.

But these indicators do not necessarily mean the business model is economically sustainable.

The critical questions are:

  • Is the organisation generating sustainable operating cash flow?
  • Is capital being allocated efficiently?
  • Can it survive without exceptional external support?
  • Are returns on capital adequate?
  • Is growth being financed by genuine earnings or by continually increasing leverage?

These questions move the discussion from appearance to economic substance.


11. Financial Doping Is Different from Financial Engineering

This distinction is particularly important for finance professionals. Not every sophisticated financial structure constitutes financial doping.

Businesses legitimately use:

  • debt financing;
  • equity financing;
  • leasing;
  • securitisation;
  • derivatives;
  • tax planning;
  • working-capital facilities;
  • project finance;
  • private equity;
  • venture capital.

These are ordinary instruments of modern finance. The concern begins when financial engineering is used to misrepresent economic reality, circumvent legitimate restrictions, or sustain an otherwise unviable competitive position. Therefore: Financial innovation creates value when it improves the allocation of capital. Financial doping creates distortion when it obscures or artificially enhances economic capacity.


12. The Procurement and Supply-Chain Dimension

Financial doping also has implications for procurement and supply-chain management.

Suppose Supplier A has:

  • strong cash flow;
  • healthy working capital;
  • sustainable margins;
  • efficient production.

Supplier B has:

  • weak cash flow;
  • high debt;
  • recurring losses;
  • but substantial external financial support.

Supplier B may offer extraordinarily low prices simply because its financial backers are effectively subsidising its operations. A procurement team focusing only on purchase price might select Supplier B. But a robust procurement process should consider Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) and supplier financial resilience. Why?

Because the apparent saving may disappear if the supplier subsequently:

  • fails to deliver;
  • enters insolvency;
  • reduces quality;
  • cannot fund inventory;
  • suffers production disruption;
  • requests price increases;
  • or defaults on contractual obligations.

Thus, financial doping can become a supplier-risk issue. The cheapest supplier is not necessarily the lowest-cost supplier.


13. The Hidden Cost of Artificially Cheap Capital

One of the most dangerous aspects of financial doping is that the immediate benefit is visible while the eventual cost may be hidden.

Immediate benefit:

More money → more spending → more growth → more market share.

Long-term consequences:

Debt accumulation → resource misallocation → weaker competitors → distorted prices → financial instability → eventual restructuring.

The World Bank has highlighted how non-viable firms can absorb resources that would otherwise be allocated to healthier businesses, delaying the redeployment of capital to more productive sectors. (World Bank)

This is why financial doping should not be assessed solely by asking: “Did the funding create growth?” A better question is: “Did the funding create sustainable economic value?”


14. Financial Doping Can Be Self-Reinforcing

One of the most fascinating characteristics of financial doping is its potential to become a cycle.

Consider this:

Financial support

↓

Greater spending capacity

↓

Better assets / players / technology / market presence

↓

Improved performance

↓

Higher revenues or market valuation

↓

Greater borrowing capacity

↓

More financial support

↓

Further expansion

The organisation can therefore move further and further away from the financial position that its original operating economics would have produced. This is why financial regulators often focus not simply on whether money is available, but on where the money comes from, how it is recognised and whether the resulting economic position is sustainable.


15. Does Financial Doping Always Produce Success?

No. This is another important qualification. Money can buy resources, but resources must still be converted into performance. An organisation can receive enormous amounts of funding and still fail because of:

  • poor leadership;
  • weak governance;
  • inefficient procurement;
  • bad investment decisions;
  • poor talent management;
  • corruption;
  • weak strategy;
  • excessive bureaucracy.

Financial capital is therefore an enabler, not a guarantee. The empirical football literature nevertheless finds a relationship between financial investment and sporting performance, which explains why financial regulation has become such an important issue in elite sport. (Taylor & Francis Online)


16. Financial Fair Play: Can Regulation Stop Financial Doping?

UEFA introduced Financial Fair Play partly in response to concerns about the financial sustainability of European football.

Interestingly, empirical research into the English Premier League found that Financial Fair Play improved clubs' profitability by encouraging better management of the relationship between relevant income and expenditure. However, the study did not find evidence that this improvement necessarily translated into better financial sustainability, with debt remaining an issue. (DOI)

This illustrates a fundamental regulatory challenge: Stopping excessive spending is not the same as creating financial health. A club can comply with one financial metric while still having:

  • significant debt;
  • weak cash flow;
  • deferred obligations;
  • high transfer liabilities;
  • structural financial risk.

Regulation therefore has to look beyond a single ratio.


17. The Bigger Economic Lesson

Financial doping raises a profound question about capitalism: Should every organisation compete with whatever financial resources it can obtain, or should markets impose some boundaries on the way those resources can be used? There is no simple answer. Investment is essential to economic development. External finance can:

  • create jobs;
  • finance innovation;
  • accelerate growth;
  • build infrastructure;
  • rescue strategically important businesses;
  • fund new technologies.

But poorly structured financial support can also:

  • preserve inefficiency;
  • distort competition;
  • encourage excessive risk-taking;
  • misallocate capital;
  • increase systemic risk.

The objective should therefore not be to eliminate external finance. It should be to ensure that finance supports productivity rather than permanently replacing it.


18. Three Questions Every Business Leader Should Ask

Whether you are running a football club, manufacturing company, SME or multinational organisation, three questions are particularly useful.

Question 1: Where is the money coming from?

Is growth being funded by:

  • operating cash flow?
  • genuine investment?
  • debt?
  • subsidies?
  • related parties?
  • shareholder support?

Question 2: What is the money producing?

Is additional capital creating:

  • productivity?
  • innovation?
  • sustainable revenue?
  • competitive advantage?
  • positive cash flow?

Or is it simply covering recurring losses?

Question 3: What happens when the money stops?

This may be the most revealing question of all. If the organisation cannot survive when exceptional funding disappears, perhaps the funding has been masking rather than solving the underlying problem.


In Conclusion, Money Should Fund Performance, Not Manufacture It

Financial doping is ultimately about the relationship between capital and performance.

Money matters. Capital matters. Investment matters. But sustainable performance requires more than money. It requires productivity, innovation, governance, discipline, strategy and value creation.

The football evidence demonstrates how financial resources can influence competitive performance. Research on zombie firms demonstrates how continued financial support can preserve inefficient organisations and distort resource allocation. And contemporary regulatory cases demonstrate the difficulty of determining whether financial support represents legitimate investment or an attempt to circumvent financial constraints. (DOI)

The ultimate lesson for business leaders, investors, regulators and procurement professionals is simple: Capital should be the fuel for sustainable performance – not a substitute for it. An organisation that needs exceptional financial oxygen every year may not have solved its underlying problem. It may simply have become better at buying time. And that is perhaps the most dangerous form of financial doping: When money does not make an organisation stronger – it merely makes its weakness harder to see.


Key empirical evidence at a glance

Area

Empirical evidence

What it illustrates

English Premier League

Research found pre-FFP player expenditure could be funded through owner and bank loans beyond operating revenues

External finance can increase competitive spending capacity (DOI)

Premier League financial regulation

FFP was associated with improved profitability, although debt/sustainability problems remained

Profitability and financial sustainability are not identical (DOI)

Global firms

Study covering 79 countries found zombie firms represented roughly 10% of observations

Zombie firms are a widespread international phenomenon (ScienceDirect)

Chinese manufacturing

Zombie firms were found to be larger, less productive and to receive higher subsidy rates on average

Subsidies can sometimes sustain inefficient firms (Wiley Online Library)

Chinese industrial firms

Research found moral hazard made subsidies less effective for zombie firms

Repeated financial support can weaken incentives for improvement (ScienceDirect)

Manchester City

2026 independent commission found financial-rule breaches involving alleged misrepresentation of equity funding as sponsorship; City denies the findings and plans to appeal

The regulatory challenge of distinguishing genuine commercial revenue from disguised funding (Reuters)

On a final note, “Financial doping” is not a universally defined accounting or economic offence. In academic literature it is most established as a concept in sports economics. Its use in the wider corporate/economic context is best understood as an analytical extension describing situations where exceptional or subsidised finance artificially sustains or enhances competitive performance. (Taylor & Francis Online)


'Segun-Martins Ogunyemi, FCA
...creating & adding values with ICE (Integrity, Contentment & Excellence)

 

Beyond Services: Why Developing Economies Need Stronger Agricultural and Manufacturing Sectors

 A nation's economic future cannot be secured by services alone. Sustainable development requires productive farms, competitive factorie...